"We won't go in with preconceptions of the cast because we don't know them, and I think that will be fascinating," Cumming tells PEOPLE

NBC has picked up a version of the game that will feature civilian players, rather than the reality TV veterans and other celebrities who have populated Peacock’s iteration of The Traitors. Alan Cumming, who hosts the Peacock show, will also lead the NBC version.

Now, NBC is ready to deploy the idea of a Traitors for the rest of us in full, as the network just announced it’s ordered its own, completely non-celebrity version of the massively successful social deduction game show.