DJ LeMahieu hit a ball down the first base line in extra innings and it was ruled a foul ball even after replay review. Aaron Boone tossed his gum and was ejected. LeMahieu would also get ejected after his at bat. The Yankees lost this game in extra innings 👀 pic.twitter.com/R5o8PUwDQ3

After Judge extended the game with a dramatic game-tying home run in the top of the ninth inning, ex-Yankee Carlos Narváez won it for the Red Sox.

In the top of that inning, Anthony Volpe, the Yankees’ automatic runner, was thrown out trying to steal third base with nobody out. He was initially ruled safe at third, but the call was overturned after Boston challenged the play.